On November 21, all trading pairs with the Canadian dollar broke on Kraken. For several hours, Bitcoin there cost half as much as on other platforms.
Kraken is a crypto exchange. A pair with the Canadian dollar means that Bitcoin is bought and sold on it for Canadian dollars.
The cheap Bitcoin went mainly to those who already had Canadian dollars sitting on the exchange.
How the price fell
- Start. A trader under the nickname greb wrote on X that all CAD pairs were trading at roughly 30% below the market. BTC converted came out to about $39,000, and the US dollar was being given away for 70 Canadian cents.
- Half an hour later. Julian Figueroa, co-founder and host of The Exit Manual show, noticed the same thing.
- An hour after that. greb reported a price of about $27,000.
- The minimum. The founder of the SearchFi project under the nickname ZAMA_APPLE recorded 24,250 CAD per BTC, which is about $17,000. Around the world at that time, BTC was trading at about $57,600.
- By 12:00 Moscow time. The BTC/CAD pair in the Kraken Pro terminal cost 40,573 CAD, about $28,800, versus $57,700 on other exchanges.
There was also a rebound. Before that, within the day the price had managed to jump to 80,000 CAD.
Why the gap wasn't closed
Arbitrageurs couldn't get money in. Arbitrageurs buy an asset where it's cheaper and sell it where it's more expensive.
- Proof of residence in Canada and a local bank account.
- Transfer via Interac - the Canadian payment system.
- Weekend - banks block some transfers.
- 10,000 CAD per day - the maximum account top-up.
The order book got skewed. There are few buyers in it, and many sellers.
Has this happened before
Opinions on the cause diverged. ZAMA_APPLE links the skew to limits on CAD top-ups, greb to a breakdown inside the exchange.
- Upbit, 2018 - BTC on the Korean exchange cost 30-50% more than the global market.
- The "kimchi premium" - that's what this markup was called. Korea restricted currency transfers abroad, and local demand was greater than the available coins.
- Kraken - the skew is the opposite: the coins are there, but there aren't enough Canadian dollars to buy them up.
What this means for a trader
The main thing: such a price is taken by someone who already has Canadian dollars sitting on the exchange.
How prop trading, challenges and payouts are structured is covered in the academy.
It's convenient to look for a program for your market using the challenge selector.
Saw a screenshot with BTC at $17,000?
You want to buy up an order book like that, but everything comes down to access. You need Canadian dollars already in the account and a limit that will let them through. In prop programs, such a trade is checked separately: in some places arbitrage and entries at a clearly non-market quote are prohibited, and profit on them won't be approved. This is in the risk rules that are read before paying for the evaluation. The list of programs where such trading is allowed can be put together with a selector in a minute.

