Traders' chat: what it is and how it differs from a channel
A chat on Telegram usually means a group. Everyone in it writes: they reply to each other, argue about trades, post charts. A group holds up to 200,000 people. A channel works differently. It is a broadcast, posts come out under the channel's name, there can be any number of subscribers, and only the admin can write.
For verification, the difference is significant. In a channel you see what the author decided to show. In a group you see live discussion: who asks questions, what they answer to a losing trade, whether there is anyone there besides the author and a couple of assistants.
| Channel | Group (chat) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who writes | Admin under the channel's name | Any member |
| How many people | Unlimited | Up to 200,000 |
| What for | Broadcast | Discussion with replies |
| What to check | Who the author is and what they sell | Pinned post, history, members |
- Channel
- Admin under the channel's name
- Group (chat)
- Any member
- Channel
- Unlimited
- Group (chat)
- Up to 200,000
- Channel
- Broadcast
- Group (chat)
- Discussion with replies
- Channel
- Who the author is and what they sell
- Group (chat)
- Pinned post, history, members
Green marks the winner in each row
The group owner has settings that change the picture. They can hide the history from new members, and then you won't see what was written a month ago. They can hide the member list: only admins will see it, and you won't be able to count the real people. They can require approval to join and enable anti-spam.
These settings by themselves mean nothing bad. Anti-spam is needed in a large chat, and approval requests filter out bots. It's worth getting suspicious when everything is hidden at once and the only thing left in plain sight is screenshots of profits.
According to Telegram founder Pavel Durov, the messenger has more than 1 billion monthly active users (RIA Novosti, 19.03.2025). With an audience like that, choosing among trader chats on Telegram is hard. Roundups of "best channels" on the internet rank them, but they usually don't provide verifiable data behind the ranking. So check the chat yourself: by the pinned post, the history and the replies.
Trader community: how it helps a beginner
A trader community gives a beginner what a textbook doesn't: live questions and answers. You see how others set a stop, how they cope with a losing streak, what they write after blowing a deposit. That makes it easier to understand how much risk there is in trading, and it's free.
A good sign is discussion of ideas with reasoning. A member posts a trade, explains why they entered and where the stop is, and the others argue and find weak spots. A bad sign is a stream of ready-made entries with no explanation, under which everyone writes "in, thanks".
The Bank of Russia's "Financial Culture" portal gives a criterion for paid education, and it applies to chats too. It advises choosing courses where they give homework, check it, go over mistakes and answer questions. It also warns there: bloggers' courses cost from a couple of thousand to several tens of thousands of rubles, and a high price doesn't guarantee quality.
A chat won't give you a system. The answers in it are scattered: one piece of advice today, the opposite tomorrow. The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) states outright that you can't make decisions based only on information from group chats. It's more convenient to build your foundation according to a plan, for example the 90-day trading plan from scratch, and come to the chat with specific questions.
The formats a beginner encounters on Telegram are structured differently:
- Free to enter, anyone can post. You can see how trades are discussed, but signal sellers come there too.
- read and ask questions
- You pay for ready-made entries and exits. Such a channel only teaches you to copy other people's trades.
- not for the SpiceProp and HyroTrader challenge
- Inside are those who met a condition, for example bought a challenge. It's harder for a random outside seller to get in. Entry doesn't guarantee profit.
- for those already trading
Trading on Telegram: how signal sales work
A signal is a ready-made trade: what to buy, where the stop is, where to take profit. Some trading chats on Telegram make their money selling such signals by subscription. Some simply take money for other people's entries. Others work according to a scheme that regulators consider the start of investment fraud.
In a warning dated 22.12.2025, the SEC writes: be careful with any group chat where investment advice is given by someone you don't know; fraud often starts this way. A chat may be run in the name of a well-known guru, sometimes with a fake video (deepfake), or it may be run by a completely made-up leader.
The same warning covers the SEC case against Morocoin. Four "clubs" recruited people through social media ads and invited them into WhatsApp chats. Each chat had a "professor" with commentary and his "assistant". Trades followed "artificial intelligence signals", and participants sent screenshots of successful trades and praised the signals.
Scheme based on the SEC warning of 22.12.2025. Profit on the screen proves nothing. The account shows "earnings", but when withdrawing, they ask you to pay a commission, tax, or make a deposit. Sometimes the victim is told that the SEC itself "froze" the account and that a fee must be paid to unfreeze it.
Pump in the chat: who buys last
The second scenario is pump and dump. The organizers inflate the price of a stock or coin with false claims, and then sell it to the chat participants. Scientists who studied cryptocurrency pumps counted 412 such pumps in Telegram channels in just eight months, from June 2018 to February 2019. Another group of researchers monitored pump organizers for more than three years, found about 900 separate cases, and writes that such groups usually operate on Telegram and Discord.
According to the US broker regulator FINRA, complaints about "investment groups" from social media have been growing since autumn 2023. In July 2025, the FBI gave a figure: complaints about ramp-and-dump (the same price inflation) have increased by at least 300% compared to 2024.
What the Bank of Russia writes
In 2025, the Bank of Russia identified 7,087 entities with signs of illegal activity, 21.5% fewer than a year earlier. Pyramid organizers used more than 7 thousand websites, 350 Telegram channels, and more than 180 social media pages. According to the regulator, pseudo-brokers still favor schemes with educational courses and simulated trading, and they look for clients through "personal consultations" in Telegram channels and cold calls.
The share of pyramids that accepted contributions in cryptocurrency, according to the Bank of Russia's 2025 review. The SEC also calls transferring crypto to an unfamiliar wallet a suspicious method of payment.
Where they teach and where they sell: how to tell by the pinned post and replies
A study chat and a signal seller give themselves away in the same places: the pinned post, the reaction to losses, and the talk about money. The SEC calls promising high returns with low or no risk a classic sign of fraud and adds that guaranteed high returns do not exist.
| They teach | They sell signals | |
|---|---|---|
| Income | They don't promise, they talk about risk | Percentages per month, guarantee |
| In the pinned message | Rules and breakdowns | Payment and VIP |
| Losing trades | They break them down | They don't show them |
| Question about the stop | They answer in the general chat | They invite you to DMs |
| Payment | For a course with assignment checks | To a person's card or in crypto |
- They teach
- They don't promise, they talk about risk
- They sell signals
- Percentages per month, guarantee
- They teach
- Rules and breakdowns
- They sell signals
- Payment and VIP
- They teach
- They break them down
- They sell signals
- They don't show them
- They teach
- They answer in the general chat
- They sell signals
- They invite you to DMs
- They teach
- For a course with assignment checks
- They sell signals
- To a person's card or in crypto
Green marks the winner in each row
Pay special attention to those who message you first in DMs. When a stranger starts a conversation, Telegram shows a page about them: their country, registration date, and shared groups. Telegram's help section explains why this is needed: to spot a scammer before replying. From there you can also block and report them.
Reporting is worthwhile: Telegram's terms prohibit sending spam through the service and deceiving users. A report via Report goes to Telegram moderators. If an account is reported for unsolicited messages, it will only be able to write to those who have its number saved in their contacts. Channels that lure subscribers with giveaways and then reverse the payment through the bank can be marked SCAM by Telegram and removed from search.
FINRA advises treating financial advice and stock tips in encrypted group chats with suspicion, especially if you have never met the adviser in person. A "manager" who, after your question in the general chat, writes to you in DMs offering to "manage your account" fits this advice completely.
The same logic applies to prop firms. Don't buy anything from someone who introduced themselves in the chat as a prop firm employee. First open its card in the PMC catalog: it has the overall rating, payout rules, and reviews. How to read reviews and tell paid ones apart is covered in the article about prop firm reviews.
Red flags: checking a traders' chat in 5 minutes
Five minutes means four actions. Open the pinned message and read it in full. Scroll back through the history a month: if you can't see it, that's already an answer. Open the member list. And ask a question about risk in the general chat: "where's the stop on this trade and how much can be lost."
After that, check against the list. One flag is enough not to pay and not to transfer money.
Take the test for the chat you want to check:
Even if the chat passes the test as clean, don't open trades based on other people's words there. The chat is suitable for questions and discussions; the decision about a trade remains yours.
Traders' club: what they charge for and whether it's legal
A closed traders' club usually sells entry by subscription: analytics, signals, sometimes education. Before paying, check the same things as in an open chat, and one more: who receives the money and for what exactly. If they're selling you education, the yardstick is the same as the Bank of Russia's for courses: assignments, assessment, review of mistakes, answers to questions. If they're selling signals and "income," that's no longer education.
| Subscription club | Club with entry by condition | |
|---|---|---|
| How to get in | Pay for access | Meet a condition |
| Who's inside | Anyone who paid | Anyone who met the condition |
| What does the club live on? | On subscriptions | On the core service |
| Seller's side | Can buy entry | Harder to get in |
- Subscription club
- Pay for access
- Club with entry by condition
- Meet a condition
- Subscription club
- Anyone who paid
- Club with entry by condition
- Anyone who met the condition
- Subscription club
- On subscriptions
- Club with entry by condition
- On the core service
- Subscription club
- Can buy entry
- Club with entry by condition
- Harder to get in
Green marks the winner in each row
Is it legal to sell signals
For securities in Russia, there is a rule. Under Article 6.1 of the law "On the Securities Market," individual investment recommendations are given by an investment adviser: a legal entity or an individual entrepreneur that is a member of a self-regulatory organization. Only they may use the words "investment adviser" in an organization's name. This law does not directly apply to cryptocurrency and prop challenges, but a person who advises you on specific stocks for money without the status is already operating outside the rules.
Abroad, regulators catch such advisers. In June 2025, nine regulators from the UK, Australia, Canada, Hong Kong, Italy, and the UAE held a week of action against illegal finfluencers (bloggers who promote financial products). In the UK, there were 3 arrests as a result. Steve Smart of the UK regulator FCA said that bloggers can promote financial products only if they have the right to do so.
The Bank of Russia separately warns about pyramids: they promise ultra-high returns, advertise aggressively on trendy topics like cryptocurrency, and often require an initial deposit. Organizing a pyramid carries liability under Article 14.62 of the Code of Administrative Offenses and Articles 172.2 or 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. You can report such a scheme through the Bank of Russia's online reception.
Signals from chat and prop challenge
If you came to the chat for trades for a prop account, first read the prop firm's rules. A prop firm lets someone trade with its account if they have passed a paid evaluation, the challenge. If you are just getting acquainted with this model, start with the article on how a prop account and challenge work.
Trading on someone else's signals in a challenge can cost you your account. In SpiceProp's general terms, clause 4.2.1, copying trades from external accounts, from third-party signal providers, and from traders outside SpiceProp is strictly prohibited. You may only copy from your own funded account to your own challenge. SpiceProp calls such copying a material breach of contract.
HyroTrader, in its blog about bots on a challenge, says the same: a ready-made or purchased bot with someone else's strategy, copy trading, account mirroring, and third-party signal services are not allowed. This risks an account review, restrictions, or disqualification. The prop firm's explanation is brief: the challenge tests your trading, so the strategy must be yours too.
| Signals from the chat | Own strategy | |
|---|---|---|
| SpiceProp | Prohibited | Yes |
| HyroTrader | Not allowed | Yes |
| What does the challenge check? | Other people's decisions | Your trading |
| If violated | The account may be closed | Standard limits |
- Signals from the chat
- Prohibited
- Own strategy
- Yes
- Signals from the chat
- Not allowed
- Own strategy
- Yes
- Signals from the chat
- Other people's decisions
- Own strategy
- Your trading
- Signals from the chat
- The account may be closed
- Own strategy
- Standard limits
Green marks the winner in each row
Read the rules of other prop firms about signals and copying before buying: look in the terms for clauses about copy trading, signals and third-party services. You can ask a question about the rules of a specific prop firm to PMC support on Telegram.
The challenge is paid, most participants do not pass it, and the fee is not refunded if you fail. The account is usually simulated, and the prop firm pays the payout from its own funds according to the terms of the contract.
We break down how much an attempt costs and what expenses are not visible in the price in our analysis of prop challenge prices.
PropMarketCap prop trader community: how to get in
PropMarketCap has its own private prop trader community on Telegram. There is no publicly available link to it, and you cannot buy entry separately either. It opens with Membership status, and the first level, Silver, appears after purchasing any challenge through PropMarketCap.
All three tiers — Silver, Gold, and Diamond — provide access to a private Telegram community, the Academy, and assistance with disputes. Gold is granted to those with a confirmed payout of $1,000 or more from a challenge purchased through PMC. Diamond is for those with confirmed payouts totaling $25,000 or more.
In a dispute with a prop firm, PMC acts as an additional party. The Membership page explicitly states that a result in the trader's favor is not guaranteed. The community does not promise profits either. It filters out random people: only those who purchased a challenge through PMC get inside.
If you're still far from a challenge, start with the open part of the PMC Academy: 4 out of 28 lessons are free, including a lesson on how to read challenge rules.
Summary
A Telegram traders' chat helps when people learn in it: they analyze trades, argue, and openly show losses. A promise of income, payment to a person's card, and a fee for withdrawal mean it's time to leave the chat. If you already trade a challenge, look for a community with conditional entry: Membership PMC opens a private Telegram community after purchasing any challenge via PropMarketCap.
A community you can't get into via a link from an ad
The closed PMC Telegram community opens after purchasing any challenge via PropMarketCap. Plus the Academy and help with disputes.
Find out how to get MembershipDetails and terms on the Membership pageTrading on financial markets involves a risk of losing funds. A challenge fee is not an investment and may not be returned. The material is informational and is not financial advice.